Will the U.S. Have Post Election Buyer's Remorse?

After Great Britain formally withdrew from the European Union nearly two years ago, a move known as Brexit, it didn’t take long for those who voted for withdrawal from the economic agreement among European nations to regret their decision. Similarly, it took only six weeks for the British electorate to regret having voted for Liz Truss as Prime Minister, a post she was forced to leave after just six weeks in office.  Both the Brexit decision and the appointment of Truss were achieved by Britain’s conservative party and its leadership, both of which will likely fall to the labor party in the next election if not sooner.

 

With U.S. midterm elections upon us, one can’t help wondering if we too will experience buyer’s remorse in the months to come if our now dangerous and dystopian conservative party wins a majority in either or both Congressional chambers, and/or state and local offices.

 

How that could happen is incredible to those of us among the majority of American voters, not all of whom are radically left leaning, given what we know is at stake. How, we ask ourselves, can people vote against their own interests? How could they not realize what will happen if the Republican party succeeds in promulgating hideous legislation that blatantly favors the wealthy and the white, while punishing workers and women, as well as multitudes of others? How could they prioritize gas prices over fascism?

 

It isn’t just America’s elderly, poor, black and brown people, disabled citizens, and children who will suffer most. It’s females whose bodies will be owned by the state. It’s the LBGTQ community who will not be able to marry the person they love. It’s increasing gun violence and domestic terrorism. It’s banned and burned books, control of school curricula, inaccessible quality healthcare in a time of unending pandemics. It’s the continuation of a failing infrastructure that could cost lives, and threats to the planet on which we all live.

 

The answer to the question “how could that happen here?” is that the demise of democracy as we know it at risk because white supremacy and institutionalized racism –fascism’s core – has existed since America was founded. It’s the foundation of privilege built by orchestrated fear of, control over, and willful punishment directed at immigrants, indigenous people, people of color and other cultures, and those who disagree with dangerously selfish and destructive power grabs by narcissistic maniacs and their acolytes who want a share of wealth and power. At its worst it condemns, attacks, imprisons, deports, and one way or another eliminates “the Other.”

 

Should Republicans come into power legislators like Rick Scott of Florida will work to promote his “Rescue America” plan which sound great, but really means that Social Security and Medicare would be renegotiated every five years and could ultimately be so diminished that our elders will be doomed to live in poverty and possibly die from lack of needed healthcare.

 

South Carolina’s Lindsay Graham and other Republicans want to see “entitlement reform” which means steep cuts to Social Security along with a raised retirement age. Medicare, Medicaid, and badly needed prescription drug reform, including the right to negotiate prices with Big Pharma and cap insulin cost would be compromised at best. Meanwhile Marco Rubio is waiting to repeal President Biden’s Inflation Reduction Act that among other things caps prescription costs for Medicare beneficiaries.

 

Kevin McCarthy, who would be Speaker of the House should Republicans win, is threatening to hold the U.S. debt limit hostage to policy changes, even though it was Republicans who added massively to the national debt because of their tax cuts to corporations and obscenely wealthy individuals.

 

Basically, Republicans simply want to reverse, nullify, limit, or kill all the achievements of the Biden Administration, US citizens be damned.

 

America as we’ve known it is truly at risk in a way that most of us have never known or acknowledged in our lifetimes, despite the fact that racism and white supremacy have always been part of our life and legacy. It is time now, before it’s too late for generations to come, that we recognize the underbelly of our country in order to save it and make it whole, and that we ensure common cause so that we can grow and thrive as a free and feeling nation.

 

Politically, we have two kinds of needs. The first is practical. The second is strategic. Right now, voting is a practical need that is immediate, easy to do with quick results. It’s not as controversial as strategic needs which include long term work and social change, like giving women the right to vote. Strategic needs are aimed at equity, freedom, and democracy. We have to address them too, but they will not be easy or quick.

 

Our task now is to embrace voting to save what we value. That right and responsibility has never been more urgent. But our responsibility doesn’t end with voting. It begins there and leads to doing the hard work of defending, perpetuating, and securing democracy. Only then can we recover from our present trauma and begin to rebuild a stronger, better nation that is sustainable, inclusive, equitable, and empathetic than the one we find ourselves in at this crucial moment.

 

Guns, Voting Rights, an Election and Cognitive Dissonance

Over the July 4the weekend, 160 people died from gun violence in America. One was a six-year old in Philadelphia, another was an eight-year old in Atlanta, and a third was a 15-year old in New York. Chicago saw the worst of it with 17 people fatally shot including two children. Sixty-three others were wounded. And that’s just the count for the holiday weekend. 

Research conducted recently by the University of California/Davis revealed a link between the rise in violence in the country and a surge in gun-buying since Covid-19 began, with over two million more guns sold in a three-month period this spring.

Given the continuing lack of gun safety legislation, and the increasingly public displays of white supremacy, the increase in gun sales shouldn’t come as a surprise. Violence of all kinds is on the rise.  The question is, Why haven’t more Americans been proactive on the issue of community gun violence as we face a November election? How is it that post Columbine, Newtown, Pulse and all the rest, we haven’t taken to the streets as we did for #BLM?

As Elizabeth Warren wrote in her 2015 book A Fighting Chance, “If a mysterious virus started killing eight children every day [as gun violence does], America would mobilize teams of doctors and public health officials. We’d move heaven and earth until we found a way to protect our children. But not with gun violence.” (It was an eerily prescient analogy.)

The death of civil rights icon Congressman John Lewis reminds us of another problem that plagues us as we draw closer to the most critical election in our lives. Remember that the Voting Rights Act of 1965 eliminated legal barriers at state and local levels that kept African Americans from voting. But in 2013 the Supreme Court, headed by Chief Justice Roberts, effectively struck down the Voting Rights Act in a decision that allowed Republican states to enact voter ID laws, roll back early voting, and purge voter registration lists. Last year the Roberts court also barred challenges in federal court to partisan gerrymandering. Why in this now fragile democracy aren’t we repeating the brave and bold actions of the Civil Rights Movement to ensure that everyone has the opportunity to cast their ballot?

With secret government “police” being deployed to U.S. cities to kidnap and arrest journalists and citizens exercising their constitutional right to free speech, and with a runaway pandemic raging, which is nothing short of negligent homicide on the part of the president, why are we not in the streets demanding that Donald Trump resign (as Russians are now doing to oust Putin)?

As one friend put it, “You wouldn’t stay married to a serial killer, so why are so many Americans still putting up with Trump?”

The answer may lie in the concept of cognitive dissonance, defined by psychologists as “having inconsistent thoughts, beliefs, or attitudes, especially relating to behavioral decisions and attitude change.”

Cognitive dissonance includes feeling discomfort when a behavior or attitude is in conflict with one’s values and beliefs, or when new information is contrary to those beliefs. A sign of the phenomenon is ignoring facts and therefore making irrational decisions, according to experts, which goes a long way in explaining why so many people aren’t wearing masks – or still insist on thinking that Trump is an effective leader.

Interestingly, when people experience an inconsistency between what they believe and how they behave, they often take actions, or don’t take them, to help reduce growing discomfort. So, for example, they may reject, explain away, or avoid information, even when that information is vital to their health and safety, or saving the country. They may grow angry at forced compliance (masks), avoid learning (fact-finding), and find decisions hard to make, but once a decision is made, it is justified as the best available option.

Donald Trump is clearly experiencing cognitive dissonance in the extreme, along with his other psychological disorders. His thought processes are deeply damaged (and limited to begin with), he is totally irrational, and his paranoia and narcissism only add to the dangerous mix.

Although I’m not a psychologist, I suspect that other Republicans who cannot stand up to Trump despite knowing he is dangerously delusional struggle privately with their own cognitive dissonance. As for mask refusing, fact denying, irrational decision-makers, it’s a possible explanation for their strange and troubling behavior.

The rest of us are understandably fatigued, frightened, and feeling fragile, which makes marching in the streets at the risk of being picked up by gun toting government goons less than appealing. Still, we must act to protect ourselves from the overt fascism that is coming straight at us, and we must overwhelmingly Vote Blue in November or our current nightmare will not end.

We would do well to remember the words of the late John Lewis: “Do not get lost in a sea of despair. … [And] Never, ever be afraid to make some noise and get in good trouble, necessary trouble.”

Whatever form it takes, and psychology aside, the time for trouble that we create is now.

                                                            # # #

 

Elayne Clift writes from Saxtons River, Vt. www.elayne-clift.com

 

Judging the Judges: It's Not Just the White House We Vote For

 

The first time I was eligible to vote I would have cast an enthusiast vote for John F. Kennedy’s second term. In the intervening years between then and now I voted only once with full enthusiasm, for Barack Obama.  My votes have largely been by default to Democratic candidates. But each time I voted I thought beyond who would occupy the White House. I knew I was also voting for lifelong federal judges who would be appointed by the president, not without bias.

 

It has never been more important than it is now for all enfranchised Americans to vote, and to understand what is at stake, including who will sit on the nation’s most important courts for the rest of their lives, rendering deeply important decisions that will affect us for generations.

 

One look at how many judges Donald Trump has put on U.S. benches - a quarter of all circuit court judges, 43 appeals court judges and 99 district court judges at this writing- should be enough to make every voter rush to the polls in November. Since becoming president, as of November 2019, Trump had nominated 227 people to federal judgeships; 165 of them were confirmed by the Republican Senate. Over 100 vacancies remain in the federal judiciary.

Another term will likely give the president the opportunity to seat one or more conservative judges on the Supreme Court.

 

The latest confirmation of a judge seated on a U.S. District Court (in Missouri) is Sarah Pitlyk, who clerked for Brett Kavanaugh and is known for building her career on her anti-abortion and reproductive health litigation. She argues against in vitro fertilization and surrogacy and has said that birth control is rooted in eugenics. The American Bar Association (ABA) unanimously declared that she, like several other Trump appointees, is “not qualified” for the judgeship. Like many other conservatives making their way to the courts, she is young (remember, these are lifetime appointments), deeply conservative, and notably inexperienced.

 

Others like her include several judges now sitting on U.S. Courts of Appeal, the courts of last resort for almost 100 percent of cases in their respective regions. The cases they hear involve capital punishment, abortion, same-sex marriage, immigration and more. They decide about 50,000 cases a year; the Supreme Court resolves 100. The decisions these judges render will affect millions of people for generations.

 

Judge Leonard Grasz is one of them. Profiled along with others by HuffPo in November, he was unanimously deemed “not qualified” by the ABA and is said to be rude and connected to powerful politicians. He opposes LGBTQ and abortion rights and has been described as having trouble separating his role as an advocate from that of a judge.

 

Another U.S. Appeals Court judge declared “unqualified” is Jonathan Kobes, who couldn’t manage to provide sufficient writing samples to meet ABA standards. He also failed to demonstrate “an especially high degree of legal scholarship and excellent analytical and writing experience,” the ABA review revealed.

 

Then there’s Judge Neomi Rao who sits on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia. She has blamed women for date rape and published inflammatory articles on sexual assault, race and LBGTQ rights.  And Amy Coney Barrett, who thinks Roe v. Wade was “an erroneous decision” and that the Affordable Care Act’s birth control benefit is “an assault on religious liberty.” She’s on Trump’s short list for Supreme Court nominations.

 

There’s more, but let’s turn to the District Courts. Judge Matthew Kaesmaryk, who said it was a “grave mistake” to include protections for LGBTQ people in the Violence Against Women Act, and who criticized the Roe v. Wade decision, now sits on the bench overseeing the Northern District of Texas. In Louisiana Wendy Vitter, wife of former Senator David Vitter, has falsely claimed that abortion is linked to cancer, and that Planned Parenthood “kills over 150,000 babies a year.”

 

Judge Howard Nielson, Jr. of Utah has argued that a gay judge couldn’t possible be fair on a same-sex marriage case, and that sexual orientation is a choice. He also disputed evidence that LGBTQ discrimination leads to higher rates of depression and suicide.

 

A Tennessee judge, Mark Norris, has a record of Islamophobia, homophobia, and extreme anti-abortion views.  He fought against the removal of monuments glorifying Confederate leaders and established a website showing images of refugees next to ISIS terrorists.

 

And in Oklahoma, Judge Patrick Wyrick tried to make emergency contraception harder to get for minors and adults. He also filed an amicus brief in the 2014 Hobby Lobby case, arguing that the ACA’s contraceptive coverage mandate was unconstitutional because “religious faith is more than mere belief.”

 

With very few exceptions, all of these judges, and others, have received unanimous Republican confirmation in the Senate.

 

When I was teaching Women’s Studies to undergraduates, many of whom were facing their first vote, I always underscored the importance of their vote with regard to the judiciary. I told them I’d be sitting on their shoulders when they went to the polls and I hoped they’d do the right thing. Now I find myself wanting to sit on the shoulder of every single person who hopefully votes. I hope with all my heart they too will do the right thing. So very much is riding on it.

 

                                                            # # #

 

Elayne Clift writes about women, politics and social issues from Saxtons River, Vt.

www.elayne-clift.com